Some Shall Be Pardoned And Some Punished Essay

Romeo And Juliet: Who Is The Real Culprit?

“Some shall be pardoned, and some punished, for there was never a story of more woe than of Juliet and her Romeo.”

Romeo and Juliet: the story and characters that define “teenage love” and tragedy. But were the tragic misunderstandings and mishaps truly their fault? A question that has risen many a time has now been made the topic of this essay; who is really at fault for the unfortunate death of the 2 most deep lovers? Through pathetic fallacy for effect, foreshadowing, and an insightful prologue, Shakespeare gives us a preview of what was going to become of the two troubled lovers. Many characters can be held guilty for their death in various indirect ways, such as the Nurse, Capulet, Tybalt or even Romeo himself. However, can Friar Lawrence be counted in as well? In Shakespeare’s play, Romeo and Juliet, Friar Lawrence plays a very significant role as a priest of the St. Francis Church and who the children trusted completely. Shockingly, in this play of tragedy, Friar Lawrence has the bigger hand in the death of the two star-crossed lovers through means rash and hasty decisions. There are many sources of evidence proving the Friar indirectly responsible for the fate of the children, through the “much appreciated” help he has provided to the children to finally be together. However, without the Friar the children would have nobody to support their love and decisions, due to the deadly family feud between the Montagues and the Capulets. In hopes of solving the decade old dispute with no meaning, the Friar, without giving his decisions much thought, helped the children in their desperate spirit to be married and live a happy life together. Would someone consider him unaware of the intensity of the present family conditions? Or would they think of his actions as inconsiderate of the consequences that could follow? The obvious actions of the Friar can possibly point out some character traits that may support this debate of weather he is truly at fault or not.
Friar Lawrence, Romeo’s “life” mentor, has obviously advised Romeo for many things, and has definitely supported him through many of his tough times, however too much of something if never a good thing, which is the case of the Friar. His great support for Romeo and Juliet) all throughout the play, and the support Romeo has from him, has compelled the Friar to take such decisions that he may not even think out properly before he had committed to the children. Instead of giving pleasant ideas to the young children such as deciding of a way to proclaim their love to the world, as an alternative to such a hard plan he takes the easy way out and sets up the underground marriage. Knowing this was an erroneous choice to take in such a situation, he quotes: “Wisely and slow; they stumble that run fast”; a hinting phrase the Friar told Romeo before carrying on with the marriage, suggesting that perhaps they were rushing this situation. However he did believe that the children’s marriage might...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

Who is to Blame in Romeo and Juliet?

1605 words - 6 pages Who to Blame for the Deaths of Romeo and Juliet The deaths of Romeo and Juliet didn't really need to happen, as it wasn't them, but the people around them that were fighting and disagreeing. Romeo and Juliet did their best to keep out of the violence but the people around them such as family friends and the local community that were making them unhappy. Romeo is a young teenager of the Montague Household, who falls in...

Who is Responsible for the Tragic Deaths of Romeo and Juliet

1741 words - 7 pages Who is Responsible for the Tragic Deaths of Romeo and Juliet 'Romeo and Juliet', a tragedy written by William Shakespeare in the 16th Century all about two strong hearted teenagers in the city of Verona in Italy who fall in love with each other as 'star crossed lovers'. The two young teenagers of feuding families were destined to fall in love, however many problems occur to the extent of suicide, that affect their...

Who Is To Blame For The Death Of Romeo And Juliet? Word Count: 1060.

1066 words - 4 pages In William Shakespeare's play Romeo and Juliet, there is much controversy to who is to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. In this tragedy, the two family's on-going feud drives Romeo to kill one of Juliet's relatives and thus he...

Who is Most Responsible for the Deaths in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

637 words - 3 pages Who is Most Responsible for the Deaths of Romeo and Juliet Romantic love stories are often ended with a tragedy, because of loss of passion or a loved one. These tragedies are often the result of one person’s actions that ended someone’s life or love. In the Romeo and Juliet play written by William Shakespeare, two citizens of Verona come together and fall deeply in love. Unfortunately their love comes to an end, along with their lives,...

Romeo and Juliet paper who caused the tragedy

641 words - 3 pages Romeo and Juliet is one of Shakespeare's plays about tragedy. It is about two lovers who commit suicide when their feuding famillies prevent them from being together. The play has many characters, each with its own role in keeping the plot line. Some characters have very little to do with the plot but some have the plot revolving around...

That "Romeo and Juliet" is the story of a faint-hearted, melancholic young man who cannot control his emotions ...

930 words - 4 pages '"Romeo and Juliet" is the story of a faint-hearted, melancholic young man who cannot control his emotions.'Contrary to popular belief, the character of

What makes "Romeo and Juliet" a tragedy and who or what is responsible for it?

6864 words - 27 pages "Romeo and Juliet" is one of Shakespeare's most famous and classical tragic plays where two young lovers are destined to be together but their families bitter hatred towards one another force them apart. They soon realize that one cannot live without the other and would rather be dead than live apart; so they end up committing suicide under tragic...

Who is to Blame for Death in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

2691 words - 11 pages Who is to Blame for Death in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet Beliefs are rested on the idea that fate killed Romeo and Juliet. People at this time also believed in arranged marriages. However many people and things can be considered to have increased the risk of their deaths therefore who or what is to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet? Friar John must take some of the blame for their deaths, as the ...

"Romeo and Juliet": Analysis for the long feud between house and Capulet and Montagule, who is more blameworthy of the feud?

724 words - 3 pages Honor is a type of love for oneself. However, sometimes love can kill and inflict hatred for others. When one values their honor too highly it may lead to disasters and tragedies. In the play "Romeo and Juliet" the conflicts between the house of Montagues and the house of Capulets is so intense that even the slightest quarrel between the opposing family...

Who or what was to be blamed for the deaths of romeo and juliet?

1993 words - 8 pages The deaths of Romeo and Juliet appear needless, as it was mainly the people around them who were fighting and disagreeing about the relationship. Romeo and Juliet mainly kept out of the fighting but their lives were made miserable and unhappy by the people around them who were interfering, and because they were so deeply in love with each other, they refused to be split up and therefore took risks to stay together which eventually led to their...

Who was to blame for the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet?

1330 words - 5 pages Essay QuestionWho was to blame for the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet?In the following essay I am going to explore the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet and who was to blame for it.The author of the play is William Shakespeare born in Stratford in April 26, 1564. Died...


Iaquinto 2

marriage. Capulet is very angry when Juliet does not want to marry Paris. He violently screams at her for a prolonged period of time. He also says that if she was a beggar and he saw her, he would just ignore her. He shows complete disregard for her feelings. Therefore, by not caring about his daughter, this proves

how Capulet should be punished for Romeo and Juliet’s deaths.

Finally, he should be punished for not acting maturely and not ending the feud with the Montague family like an adult should. By choosing to keep the feud going, he unintentionally causes his

daughter, and nephew’s deaths. If he had ended the feud, then Tybalt would not have wanted to fight Romeo, and therefore not have died, since everything after Tybalt’s death is

negative, it can be inferred that his death is the turning point. If the feud was ended by Lord Capulet, then most likely, nobody would have died, but he did not. Hence, he should be  punished for not stopping the silly feud earlier. Consequently, by Lord Capulet moving the wedding, yelling intensely at his daughter, and not ending the feud, he should be penalized. The nurse should also be punished by Prince Escalus. First, she tells Juliet to forget about Romeo and marry Paris. When the nurse tells this to Juliet, she is betraying her trust and siding with her parents, when she

should be on Juliet’s side. The nurse says, “Romeo is  banish’d; and all the world to nothing… I think it best you married with the county” (3.5.214— 

18). By the nurse betraying her, Juliet can only trust Romeo and the Friar. Therefore, the nurse should

 be disciplined by the Prince for playing a part in Juliet’s bloodshed. Another reason is

that she does not tell Lord or Lady Capulet of the marriage of Romeo and Juliet. When they got married, the nurse chooses

not to tell Juliet’s parents. By the nurse

 not doing this, she is not allowing the parents to know what Juliet is going through. They believe she is crying over Tybalt, but if the nurse tells them, they may be more sympathetic since Lord Capulet is already  prompted to end the feud. If the nurse tells them, it might be better for Juliet in the long run.

0 Replies to “Some Shall Be Pardoned And Some Punished Essay”

Lascia un Commento

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *